Customer Reviews

Read what some of our satisfied insurance customers have to say! If you’d like to provide your feedback, please submit your online review.

  • Fadi Salim Baff
    They are very friendly like your family and very honest.

    “They are very friendly like your family and very honest.
    Wish them all the prosperity in their field of business.”

  • Kyle Rhine
    Highly recommend them for your insurance needs!

    “Very happy with the service and insurance rates provided by Cathy and team! Highly recommend them for your insurance needs!”

  • Don Klever
    They met my insurance needs exactly and they were less expensive than others.

    “I found McGuire Group to be friendly and competent. They met my insurance needs exactly and they were less expensive than others. I compliment them on their professionalism.”

  • Tracey Steele-White
    Saved me $1044 year on my auto policies.

    “Saved me $1044 year on my auto policies. A free review on your insurance needs so call anytime!”

  • John Thomas
    she the best, if you don't believe me check out your self
  •  Renae Blough-St John
    She made everything so easy and got us great rates on our new home insurance!

    “I had such a wonderful experience working with Jen! She made everything so easy and got us great rates on our new home insurance! I would recommend them to all my friends!

  •  Brandi Joslin
    ...a small business who truly cares about their about their customers.

    “If I ever have a question or concern, they are answered and explained efficiently and friendly by your amazing agents. I confidently trust them with my insurance needs.

    They’re not afraid to call, email, or text if something pops up, there’s a better insurance option, or if you have a policy change.

    They make you feel at ease, because they are a small business who truly cares about their about their customers. I would recommend them to anyone.”

  •  Christine Wasserman
    I highly recommend Cathy McGuire for her expertise...

    “After more than 40 years as a loyal customer of State Farm’s, I recently met with Cathy McGuire at Erie Insurance, Sylvania, OH (as well as a couple of other local insurance agencies) to see if I could lower my annual insurance costs. Cathy compared “apples to apples” and was able to provide the same (or better) level of auto, home and umbrella coverage as State Farm did … for nearly $300 less per year! I was very glad a neighbor highly recommended her and Erie Insurance (which is among the highest rated insurance companies in Ohio). Her staff also is very knowledgeable and welcoming. I highly recommend Cathy McGuire for her expertise, friendliness and professionalism.”

  •  Jessica Wyman
    ...the price that is affordable!

    “Very fast quote, friendly to talk to, very easy process and changing anything is very fast and simple and a big factor is the price that is affordable! Literally saved us a little over $100 each month!!! And we still have full coverage 🙂 Thanks sooo much. Glad we made the switch.”

  •  Tracy Ulrich
    The office staff and owner are amazing! They truly care about their clients.